Brian McDonagh
Marsh Captive Solutions Dublin

Many captive owners are exploring alternative forms of capital in order to strengthen their capital base in a more efficient manner, says Brian McDonagh of Marsh

How well is the Ireland insurance industry doing? Are numbers still on the up?

A review of the list of regulated insurance and reinsurance undertakings produced by the Irish regulator, the Central Bank of Ireland, shows that overall numbers for licenced insurance and reinsurance entities are down year on year, 2016 to 2017. Behind that headline number are myriad stories and views. For instance, this is a reversal of the positive developments during the 2015 to 2016 period when Ireland experienced an increase in the number of new captive authorisations issued by Central Bank of Ireland.

The continuation of the soft insurance market is probably the main driver, a story that resonates globally. Ongoing consolidation of regulated entities owned by multinationals (both captive and non-captive) could be another factor in the downward trend. However, one should not assume a trend based on a one-year review.

Surprisingly, the number of captives increased during 2015 in advance of the implementation of the new Solvency II regime. However, it does appear that the market is currently waiting to see an appropriate application of the proportionality principle to the regulation of captives (as defined within that legislation) in the new Solvency II era.

Dialogue between European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority, local supervisors and the insurance industry needs to be reflected in a proportionate approach to the supervision of captives and lower-risk entities to ensure the continued growth of ‘onshore EU’ as a sustainable location for captives.

What trends are you currently seeing in the captive insurance market in Dublin?

Under the banner of Solvency II, many captive owners are exploring alternative forms of capital, second- and third-tier capital, in order to strengthen their capital base in a more efficient manner. To date, options including the use of letters of credit, parental guarantees, subordinated debt, and unpaid share capital have received regulatory approval.

We are seeing a greater call for the services of captive managers and advisors as captives address evolving aspects of the solvency capital requirement optimisation and focus further on a fully integrated service solution across all three Solvency II pillars.

The owners and managers who have fared best through implementation are those who have invested in integrated IT platforms to ensure maximum automation with respect to solvency capital requirement calculation and reporting. This again has proved to be crucial as we move through the first annual reporting cycle due in mid-May.

Multinational organisations have increased their focus on consolidation and alignment of their global employee benefit costs, which continues to be the single biggest growth area for these firms. Many multinationals are involved in projects and feasibility work or have gone to the implementation phase, which often involves using a captive for portions of that retained employee benefit risk.

There appears to be little doubt that the sophistication by which non-life covers have been managed by multinationals for many decades will be replicated in the employee benefits space over the medium term.

Cyber is the other high profile risk area. This is reflected in the increase in the number of captives underwriting that specific risk.

Finally, there are many conversations around the virtual captive concept and once again that will continue to be an area for rapid growth.

How is the reinsurance industry developing in Dublin? Are you still attracting new clients?

My personal view is that aspects of the continued development of the reinsurance industry market have been ‘on hold’ for a number of years as the uncertainties of how the Solvency II regime will be supervised in each EU location continue to play out.

That uncertainty may now be offset by opportunities created in the aftermath of the Brexit vote and the triggering of Article 50 in the UK. Brexit represents an opportunity for the reinsurance industry and the larger international financial services industry in many EU locations, including Dublin.

Specific to the Dublin reinsurance market is the continued growth of the insurance linked-securities (ILS) sector. There have been many repeat bond issuances replacing the typical three-year cycle afforded to each catastrophe bond programme and Dublin has seen new entrance to this specialised market in the past 12 months.

How is Ireland faring against economic uncertainties at present?

There never will be, nor should there be, a period when world economic uncertainties do not have an impact on how people go about their business. How one reacts to those uncertainties determines whether these are threats or opportunities. Since the 1950s, Ireland has pursued a strategy of attracting foreign direct investment essentially to provide employment opportunities to a growing population. Since that time, Ireland has managed to remain an attractive location for multinationals by providing a well-educated English-speaking workforce and a stable commercial, business, and tax environment.

This strategy has remained the cornerstone of every government since that time and has proved to be a successful strategy even up to today. As a result, it is likely that adapting to each new global reality has been subsumed into the fabric and culture of the international financial services sector here.

How has Brexit affected Ireland as a captive insurance and reinsurance domicile?

To date, the Brexit project has being an exercise in contingency planning. While some operations currently based in London have made decisions on where and how they may reorganise themselves in a post-Brexit environment, most are still researching and/or considering their options.

The decision of ‘where’ is the opportunity for other EU financial centres, including Dublin, and we are keeping as close as possible to those prospects.

The existence of an international insurance market, combined with a regulator who has staffed up in expectation of new applications, make me optimistic that Dublin will land more than its fair share of those opportunities.

As a further angle to this, EU captives who access the UK commercial reinsurance market will also need to follow developments closely. Current thinking is that it is likely the UK will look to achieve “equivalence” similar to Bermuda, Australia, Japan, and Switzerland.

This equivalence status would be necessary to ensure appetite for EU companies to access the UK reinsurance markets.

In addition, credit ratings for reinsurers and insurers should also be closely monitored for potential downgrades and knock-on effects of the captive’s solvency capital requirement under Solvency II.

The latest interviews from Captive Insurance Times
The latest features from Captive Insurance Times
Jeremy Colombik of MSI and NCCIA chair explains to Becky Butcher that Notice 2016-66 could be detrimental to not just North Carolina, but other domiciles that are home to smaller captives
Dan Towle, president of CICA and Zach Finn, professor at Butler University, discuss their new professional development partnership, which will see students learn about the variety of career opportunities in captive insurance
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
Alan Cabello of AGCS discusses blockchain technology, captives and the future
Alan Fine of Brown Smith Wallace explains how the industry should proceed after the Avrahami court case ruling
Dana Hentges Sheridan, general counsel and chief compliance officer at Active Captive Management, provides insight into the differences between business risks and insurance risks
Predicting when interest rates will change is difficult, which is even more reason to maintain a disciplined approach to your investments, according to Stephen Nedwicki of Comerica Bank
Looking ahead to 2018, Phillip Giles of QBE North America predicts continued uncertainty for the healthcare reform
Michael Schroeder of Roundstone explains why transparency, control and cost savings are the secret sauce offered by a medical captive
Domicile profiles
The latest domicile profiles from Captive Insurance Times
Tennessee’s governor, commissioner, general assembly and business community have all worked together to create ‘explosive growth’ in the state’s captive insurance industry. Julie Mix McPeak explains more
Newly-appointed chairman of CCIA Michael Maglaras suggests that the future is bright for state’s captive industry
Asset Servicing Times

Visit our sister site
for all the latest asset servicing news and analysis
Although the Isle of Man is currently focusing on updating its regulatory framework, Solvency II, Brexit and the Asian market all hold big opportunities for the island
Debbie Walker of the North Carolina Department of Insurance tells Becky Butcher why the state is among 2017’s standout performers
Experts convene to talk to Becky Butcher about the stability that Guernsey represents in a challenging financial and political environment
In an era of increasing uncertainty, Tamatoa Jonassen suggests that the Cook Islands can be a bridge to financial security in a captive
With a dedicated captive plan in place, the Lone Star State is on the rise, says Josh Magden of the Texas Captive Insurance Association
After 36 years of captive business, Vermont boasts a culture of legislative change, and still has a few tricks up its sleeve. Dan Towle and David Provost explain