New York
22 March 2017
Reporter: Mark Dugdale

Second Circuit dismisses ‘shadow insurance’ claims


The US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit has parried two attacks against the captive reinsurance transactions of life insurance companies, ruling that the plaintiff insureds lacked the standing to bring their complaints.

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company and AXA Equitable Life Insurance were taken to federal court in New York by several insureds after the Department of Financial Services issued its controversial report on life insurers’ failure to disclose captive reinsurance transactions in 2013.

In their separate cases, the insureds claimed that Metropolitan Life and AXA Equitable misrepresented their financial strength by not properly disclosing their captive reinsurance transactions.

The life insurers’ undisclosed use of “shadow insurance” caused them injury, the plaintiff insureds argued.

They attempted to gain class-action status so they could represent insureds throughout the US, but the US District Court for the Southern District of New York dismissed their complaints due to a lack of standing under Article III of the Constitution.

Ruling in favour of Metropolitan Life and AXA Equitable at the end of February, the Second Circuit said: “The mere fact that an insurer may make a misleading representation does not require or even lead to the necessary conclusion that the misleading representation is material or even likely to cause harm.”

Commenting on the litigation, Dentons lawyers Sandra Hauser and Carter White said: “The order is a strong signal from the Second Circuit that plaintiffs who fail to demonstrate concrete, non-speculative injury lack Article III standing to sue, and also dashes future putative plaintiffs' hopes of leveraging New York's insurance laws to support lawsuits by policyholders who are not personally affected by the conduct they challenge.”

More regulation news
The latest news from Captive Insurance Times
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
UK’s ILS legislation to be in place for January renewals
17 October 2017 | London | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
Malcolm Newman, CEO of Scor’s London hub and sponsor of the London Market Group’s (LMG) ILS Taskforce is “cognisant of the time pressures if ILS applications are to be made in time for 1 January renewals”
Tennessee updates captive legislation
03 October 2017 | Nashville | Reporter: Becky Butcher
New captive legislation is to set Tennessee apart from other US captive insurance domiciles, according to the state’s Department of Commerce and Insurance (TDCI).
US and EU sign covered agreement
22 September 2017 | Brussels | Reporter: Becky Butcher
The US and EU have signed the bilateral covered agreement on insurance and reinsurance
GFSC addresses Solvency II and IAIS capital standards project
20 September 2017 | St Peter Port | Reporter: Becky Butcher
The Guernsey Financial Services Commission (GFSC) has launched a discussion paper seeking the industry’s feedback on the evolution of the island’s global and European insurance capital standards
DARAG completes Ikano captive transaction
08 September 2017 | Jerusalem | Reporter: Katherine Brown
DARAG has completed an Israeli reinsurance transaction and received regulatory approval for the acquisition of Ikano Försäkring, the Stockholm-based Swedish captive owned by Ikano Group
Avrahami might not have all the answers, says Feldman
29 August 2017 | Houston | Reporter: Becky Butcher
The US Tax Court’s ruling in Avrahami might not be the victory for the IRS that everyone thinks it is, according to Stewart Feldman, CEO and general counsel of Capstone Associated Services
Avrahami provides clarity for 831(b)s
25 August 2017 | Burlington | Reporter: Becky Butcher
The ruling of the Avrahami vs Commissioner of Internal Revenue court case finally provides additional clarity for captives organised under Section 831(b), according to Anne Marie Towle of JLT