San Diego
20 March 2017
Reporter: Becky Butcher

Captive industry meets covered agreement with mixed response


Industry response to the covered agreement between the EU and the US has been interesting and varied, according to panellists at the Captive Insurance Companies Association (CICA) International conference

The panel discussed the agreement between the EU and the US Treasury and the Office of the US Trade Representative (USTR), completed on 13 January. The agreement provides a mutual agreement of prudential supervision in the EU and the US that will eliminate the increasing barriers to US groups operating in Europe.

Panellists explained that the agreement was needed because the European Commission has not deemed the US as an equivalent jurisdiction under the Solvency II Directive, which means US companies would need to cover a lot of additional requirements in order to do business in the EU.

The agreement eliminates the requirement for a local place of business in the host jurisdiction and the requirement for collateral. It applies to companies that have more than $250 million in capital, and those with the equivalent in euro for EU countries.

Skip Myers, partner of the insurance group at Morris, Manning and Martin, suggested that reaction to the agreement has been interesting. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) has been particularly troubled by it, he said. Although it wasn’t a part of negotiations, it was an observer.

The NAIC has raised concerns about not being able to vote on the decision and around transparency, and is concerned about the provision in the agreement for foreign jurisdictions to have regulatory authority over a US company.

Myers said the NAIC is looking at the agreement and is preparing amendments to submit to the US Treasury.

Other bodies, including the Reinsurance Association of America, believe the agreement brings some predictability to their members’ participation in the European markets, and vice versa, according to Myers.

Jim McIntyre, partner of McIntyre & Lemon, added that, while the agreement might not have any direct effect on captives, it could eliminate some barriers and stabilise pricing, which is good for captives.

Finally, the panel discussed possible changes around the Affordable Care Act (ACA). Panellists suggested that, although President Donald Trump and the Republicans plan to repeal or replace the ACA, it’s unclear what the replacement will ultimately look like. Myers said: “The change, on balance, could be good for captives”.

He added: “Captives now, even under the ACA, have grown in the healthcare space in terms of medical stop-loss for employer plans and that will continue to grow. The fact the states will be more involved [will be positive]. I think we are heading for a system where there is more state control, which I think is a good thing for captives.”

More Industry news
The latest news from Captive Insurance Times
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
Madison Re II to reinsure Novea captive
21 November 2017 | Cheyenne | Reporter: Becky Butcher
Novea has selected Madison Re I.I. to reinsure its pure captive Jacana Insurance
‘Exciting developments’ in South Carolina’s captive industry
17 November 2017 | Charleston | Reporter: Becky Butcher
Jay Branum of the South Carolina Department of Insurance has revealed the state has “very positive and exciting developments” for its captive insurance industry
‘Explosive growth’ for Tennessee’s captive market
17 November 2017 | Nasville | Reporter: Lorella Fava
After rewriting its captive statute back in 2011, the captive insurance market in Tennessee has seen “explosive growth”, according to the state’s insurance commissioner Julie Mix McPeak
Captive insurance scholarships awarded in Bahamas
14 November 2017 | The Bahamas | Reporter: Lorella Fava
The Bahamas Financial Services Board (BFSB) and the Insurance Commission of The Bahamas (ICB) has selected two recipients for the Associates in Captive Insurance designation scholarships
SRS acquires Barbados captive manager
13 November 2017 | Massachusetts | Reporter: Lorella Fava
Strategic Risk Solutions (SRS) has acquired the operations of CGE Group, a Barbados captive manager
Captives dragged into Paradise Papers furore
10 November 2017 | Bermuda | Reporter: Stephanie Palmer
The captive insurance industry has for the first time been implicated in the so-called Paradise Papers, as a US businessman was identified in one of the leaked documents as a director of a captive insurer
CICA and Butler form professional development partnership
09 November 2017 | Minneapolis | Reporter: Becky Butcher
The Captive Insurance Companies Association (CICA) and the Davey Risk Management and Insurance Program at Butler University have formed a new professional development partnership