Washington DC
20 November 2017
Reporter: Becky Butcher

Avrahami motion for reconsiderations denied


Judge Mark Holmes has denied the Avrahamis’ motion for reconsideration concluding that at least one policy was so “ill-drafted” that it was both a claims-made and an occurrence policy.

In the motion, the Avrahamis argued: "There should be no reasonable dispute [that] the policies at issue were claims made policies, not occurrence policies.”

Judge Holmes explained that there was “sloppy drafting” of policy language and actuarial calculations that “did not reflect in all cases the actual policy language that then buttressed the finding of fact that Feedback was not operating like an insurance company”.

In his original ruling on 21 August, Judge Holmes confirmed that payments made to the Avrahamis by their micro captive, Feedback, fell outside of the scope of certain tax elections, including 831(b) for investment income up to $1.2 million.

In particular, the judge held that the pooling entity was not a bona fide insurance company, and that the captive did not operate like an insurance company because it issued policies with unclear and contradictory terms, and charged wholly unreasonable premiums.

In the petition against the ruling, the Avrahamis also argued that Feedback “must have operated like an insurance company because it reasonably relied upon its advisors to operate it”.

However, Judge Holmes stated that the question of whether an arrangement looks like insurance “doesn't depend on whether those appearances flowed from professional advice, but what actually happened”.

He added: “Some of the key facts were the extreme illiquidity of Feedback's investment portfolio—so skewed toward flowing funds back to the Avrahamis that it had no other significant investments—and the very telling pattern of receiving claims only after the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) started an audit.”

“Petitioners cite to no law that says there's a reasonable-reliance defence on the natural consequence of such activities.”

The judge ordered that, on or before 12 January 2018, the parties are to submit the computations under Rule 155, or file a status report describing their process.

More news
The latest news from Captive Insurance Times
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
Cayman captive industry generated $100m in 2016
14 December 2017 | Grand Cayman | Reporter: Ned Holmes
The Cayman Islands captive insurance industry generated $100 million for the island’s economy in 2016, according to a recent economic impact survey.
BDA board gains new chair
14 December 2017 | Hamilton | Reporter: Ned Holmes
Paul Scope has been elected as the new chair of the Bermuda Business Development Agency (BDA) and Shelby Weldon has been appointed to the board of directors.
Ameriprise captive rated ‘excellent’, says A.M. Best
14 December 2017 | New Jersey | Reporter: Ned Holmes
Ameriprise Captive Insurance Company (ACIC) has received a financial strength rating of “A (Excellent)” and a long-term issuer credit rating of “a+” from A.M. Best.
PRIIA to help grow Puerto Rico as a captive domicile
13 December 2017 | San Juan | Reporter: Ned Holmes
The Puerto Rico International Insurance Association (PRIIA) will play an expanded role in helping to grow the country into a leading captive insurance domicile, according to PRIIA president Hugo Cordova.
Brit launches new Bermuda-based SPI
13 December 2017 | Bermuda | Reporter: Ned Holmes
Insurance and reinsurance group Brit has launched a new Bermuda-domiciled collateralised reinsurance platform, Sussex Capital.
Two funds complete trade on ILSBlockchain
12 December 2017 | St Peter Port | Reporter: Ned Holmes
Two funds have completed what is believed to be the first secondary market securities trade on notes digitised on the ILSBlockchain, a private blockchain set up by Guernsey incorporated cell company Solidum Re.
NiSource captive rated ‘excellent’ by A.M. Best
11 December 2017 | Oldwick | Reporter: Ned Holmes
A.M. Best has given the financial strength rating of “A- (Excellent)” and the long-term issuer credit rating of “a-” to NiSource Insurance Corporation (NICI).