06 November 2017
Reporter: Becky Butcher

CIC Services: IRS court case ruling ‘disappointing’

CIC Services has said losing its court case to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) was “disappointing”.

In the ruling, handed down at the US District Court for the Eastern District of Tennessee, Judge Travis McDonough granted the IRS’s motion to dismiss. He explained that a ruling in CIC Services and Ryan’s favour would “restrain the IRS’s assessment or collection of taxes”.

In a statement, CIC Services said: “While the decision is not surprising in light of the court’s previous denial of our request for an injunction, it is still disappointing.”

CIC Services and Ryan had accused the IRS of unfairly labelling captives as tax avoiders in Notice 2016-66.

It requested for an injunction to delay Notice 2016-66 for micro captives.

The IRS’s notice expressed concern that micro captive transactions had the potential for tax avoidance or evasion.

CIC and Ryan said that the notice constitutes a “legislative-type rule” that “fails to comply with mandatory notice-and-comment requirements under the Administrative Procedures Act”, and requested a preliminary injunction that would stop the IRS from enforcing the notice’s requirements. However, in April, the court denied the request.

Sean King, principal at CIC Services, called the decision “especially disappointing” in light of a recent ruling by the United States District Court for the Western District of Texas in the Chamber of Commerce v IRS case, which went the opposite way.

King said: “Addressing the identical issue present in our case and using the same legal reasoning articulated in our briefs, that court concluded that the Chamber of Commerce’s lawsuit was not barred by the Anti-Injunction Act.”

He explained that two different judges have examined the identical issue and come to “contradictory conclusions”.

King said: “Unfortunately we were on the losing side of one of those opinions. We are considering our options.”

More news
The latest news from Captive Insurance Times
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
AIG to acquire Validus
22 January 2018 | New York | Reporter: Ned Holmes
AIG has agreed to acquire all outstanding common shares of Validus, the provider of reinsurance, primary insurance and asset management services, in a deal worth $5.56 billion
South Carolina welcomes 15 new captives
19 January 2018 | Charleston | Reporter: Becky Butcher
The South Carolina Department of Insurance has licensed a total of 15 new captives in 2017
A.M. Best withdraws SARRG ratings
19 January 2018 | Oldwick | Reporter: Ned Holmes
A.M. Best has withdrawn the credit ratings of SARRG, after the company requested to no longer participate in the rating agency’s interactive rating process
Regions Insurance promotes Mike Breedlove
19 January 2018 | Alabama | Reporter: Ned Holmes
Regions Insurance has appointed Mike Breedlove as its new executive vice president of property and casualty operations
Advantage opens Vermont office
18 January 2018 | Vermont | Reporter: Ned Holmes
Advantage Insurance has opened a new office in Vermont to support its growing captive insurance services business
Tennessee captive premiums exceed $1 billion mark in 2017
18 January 2018 | Nashville | Reporter: Ned Holmes
Tennessee-domiciled captive insurance companies exceeded $1 billion in written premiums in 2017 for the first time, according to year-end figures from TDCI
JLT IM hires new senior account manager
17 January 2018 | Vermont | Reporter: Ned Holmes
JLT IM has appointed Jocelyn Lyman as a new senior account manager